PE-backed CEOs face a brutal path to exit. Most never make it. Here's how not to be one →

Episode 37

The 1000-Day CEO · Interview

Chad Hesters: Hire the CEO Your Business Needs Next

Listen on

Hiring a CEO is one of the most important decisions a company can make. But before looking for the right person, business owners and boards need to understand what their organization actually needs.

In this episode of The 1000-Day CEO, Bill Canady speaks with Chad Hesters, CEO of Boyden, about finding the right executive leader, defining clear expectations, and building a leadership team that can deliver results.

The conversation explores how to create a CEO mandate, identify essential leadership skills, evaluate candidates based on real experience, and establish trust during the first 100 days. They also discuss how strong leaders develop their teams while protecting company values.

Four Key Takeaways

1. Define the Business Problem Before Hiring a CEO

The best executive search begins with a clear understanding of the business.

Before evaluating candidates, boards and business owners should identify the challenges their next CEO must address. These could involve improving operations, accelerating growth, strengthening leadership, or preparing the organization for its next stage.

A clear CEO mandate helps everyone involved understand what success should look like. It also makes the hiring process more focused by connecting leadership requirements directly to business goals.

2. Focus on the Leadership Skills That Matter Most

Every business needs different leadership strengths depending on its current situation.

A company going through major changes may need someone experienced in business transformation. A growing organization may need a leader who knows how to build teams, improve processes, and manage expansion.

Rather than creating a long list of ideal qualifications, companies should identify and rank the competencies that matter most.

This approach helps hiring teams separate essential skills from qualities that would simply be nice to have.

3. Evaluate Candidates Through Real Operating Experience

A strong résumé does not always tell the full story.

During an executive search, companies should look beyond job titles and past positions. Candidates need to demonstrate how they have handled real business situations.

Interview questions should explore specific examples of leadership decisions, operational challenges, team development, and measurable results.

Understanding what a candidate actually did provides a clearer picture of how they might perform in a new organization.

4. Build Trust and Develop Leaders Who Can Lead Others

A CEO cannot deliver results alone.

Strong leadership depends on building trust, communicating expectations, and developing people who can take ownership of their responsibilities.

The first 100 days are especially important because employees want to understand the direction of the company and how changes may affect them.

By listening, communicating clearly, and building strong relationships, a new CEO can reduce uncertainty and help the organization move forward.

What Chad Hesters Teaches About Hiring the Right CEO

Choosing an executive leader requires more than matching a candidate’s experience to a job description.

The hiring process should connect the company’s strategy, current challenges, leadership requirements, and expected outcomes.

Here are several important considerations from the discussion.

Start With a Clear CEO Mandate

A CEO mandate defines what the organization expects its next leader to accomplish.

It should explain the business priorities, important challenges, and capabilities required to deliver results.

When these expectations are clear, boards can evaluate candidates against the same priorities instead of relying only on personal impressions.

Match the First 100 Days to the Business Situation

Not every CEO should approach their first 100 days in the same way.

Some organizations need immediate operational improvements, while others require careful planning, stronger relationships, or a clearer strategy.

The right approach depends on the company’s circumstances.

New leaders should spend time understanding the business, listening to key stakeholders, and identifying where their attention will have the greatest impact.

Build Leaders of Leaders

As organizations grow, CEOs need people who can manage teams and make decisions without constant direction.

Developing strong leaders across the business creates accountability and allows the CEO to focus on broader priorities.

This also helps build an organization that can continue performing as responsibilities and business conditions change.

Protect Company Values While Allowing Local Autonomy

For companies operating across different locations, maintaining shared values is important.

However, teams may need flexibility in how they manage local operations.

Strong leadership creates a balance between consistent organizational principles and the freedom to make decisions that fit local business needs.

Turn Leadership Expectations Into Action

The conversation closes with an important question: What should the CEO do next?

A clear mandate is only useful when it leads to decisions and action.

Whether a company is hiring a new CEO or evaluating its current leadership, the next step is to identify the most important business priorities and determine who is responsible for delivering them.

Episode Chapters

  • 00:00 – Introduction
  • 00:51 – Your First 100 Days as CEO
  • 04:57 – Build Trust and Reduce Anxiety
  • 09:43 – Define the CEO Mandate
  • 12:05 – Prioritize Must-Have Competencies
  • 14:28 – Test Candidates with Real Examples
  • 18:15 – Match the First 100 Days to the Situation
  • 20:10 – Build Leaders of Leaders
  • 24:09 – Global Values and Local Autonomy
  • 28:03 – Look in the Mirror: The CEO’s Next Action

About Chad Hesters

Chad Hesters is the CEO of Boyden, a global executive search and leadership advisory firm.

His work involves helping organizations identify executive talent and make important leadership decisions.

In this episode, he shares practical insights into CEO selection, leadership assessment, executive hiring, and building teams that support long-term business success.

Connect with Chad:

Frequently Asked Questions

What should companies consider before hiring a CEO?

Companies should first define their business challenges, leadership priorities, and expected results. This helps them identify candidates with experience that matches the organization’s needs.

What is a CEO mandate?

A CEO mandate outlines the main responsibilities, priorities, and outcomes expected from a chief executive. It helps guide both the executive hiring process and the leader’s performance after joining the company.

How can companies evaluate executive candidates?

Organizations can ask candidates to describe real business situations, explain the decisions they made, and discuss the results they achieved. This provides more useful evidence than relying only on résumés and job titles.

Why are the first 100 days important for a new CEO?

The first 100 days help establish trust, clarify expectations, understand business challenges, and set priorities for the leadership team.

How does executive search support business growth?

Executive search helps organizations identify leaders with the experience and capabilities needed to address business challenges and achieve strategic goals.

Full Transcript

Read the full episode transcript

Free CEO Tools

Explore practical tools to evaluate business performance, profitability, and growth opportunities.

Book a Call with Bill

Looking to improve business performance or strengthen your leadership strategy?

Connect with Bill Canady

What must your next CEO deliver? Define the business problem, identify the right leadership skills, and build a team that can execute.

Consent Preferences